Pokémon Card Alteration Surge: PSA Interceptions Up Over 100%, Why Pressing and Cleaning Cross the N5/N7 Line
PSA-intercepted Pokémon alteration and counterfeit cases rose more than 100% year over year, and Pokémon cards now account for over 56% of all counterfeit submissions. Pressing creases is classified by PSA as N5 (Altered Stock) or returned as rejected, while whether cleaning external stains crosses the line remains disputed.
On this page
Alteration Cases Double: Why Pokémon Became the Epicenter
PSA-intercepted Pokémon alteration and counterfeit cases rose more than 100% year over year, and Pokémon cards now account for over 56% of all counterfeit submissions. These figures point not to a single counterfeiting method, but to an entire gray chain of "card doctoring" that has expanded from trimming edges and corners to physical pressing and chemical cleaning.
High-priced vintage cards and modern chase cards sitting in premium ranges at the same time is the entry point for understanding this shift. When a grading score difference can open up a price gap of several times, pressing out creases, washing off stains, and squaring up edges and corners become "score-boosting" methods some people are willing to try. The more cards are artificially altered on the supply side, the greater the interception pressure on grading organizations, and the higher the risk of rejection or downgrade for submitters.
What needs to be distinguished is this: the growth figure describes the relative change in intercepted cases, not the actual proportion of altered cards in the market. It is more of a signal—screening at the grading stage is becoming stricter, and processing methods that might once have slipped through are now more likely to be identified during inspection.
Pressing Creases: Maintenance or the Altered Dividing Line
The core of the dispute is what "pressing" actually changes. A crease means the paper fibers have already broken or yielded; using weights, pressing plates, or heat to make the card surface flat again only temporarily conceals the deformation—the fiber structure has not recovered. PSA explicitly classifies pressed creases as N5 (Altered Stock) or returns them as rejected.
Common myth
As long as no chemical agents are used and only physical pressing is applied, it counts as normal maintenance and not card alteration.
Physical reality
Pressing a crease changes the condition state the card presents and conceals a defect that originally existed. PSA classifies it as Altered Stock (N5) or directly returns it as rejected—this is a different matter from "maintenance."
The practical meaning of this dividing line is: grading judges the card's true current state, not its appearance after treatment. Pressing makes a crease look fainter visually, but makes the card's history untrustworthy—this is precisely the logical basis for the Altered determination.
Cleaning Stains vs. Pressing Creases: Different Risks of Two Treatments
Some users of care products believe that cleaning external stains does not change the paper, and therefore should not be treated the same as pressing creases. This disagreement is worth breaking down, because the two act on different targets and differ in detectability.
Cleaning external stains
Acts on substances attached to the card surface; supporters argue the paper itself is unchanged. But agents may seep into the paper base, alter surface gloss, or leave treatment traces—whether it crosses the line depends on the specific method and inspection results.
Pressing creases
Acts on paper fibers that have already deformed, using external force to make the card surface flat again; PSA has explicitly classified it as N5 (Altered Stock) or returned as rejected, and the criteria are relatively clear.
What the two share is that both change how the card "looks when seen"; the difference is that pressing already has a clear grading classification, while the boundary for cleaning is still under debate. For holders, treating an uncertain treatment as a safe operation is itself a risk.
After an Altered Determination: The Chain Reaction on Price and Liquidity
Once a card is judged Altered or returned as rejected, the impact goes beyond the score. The score inside a grading slab is an important anchor for pricing high-value cards; without that anchor, buyers can only bid on the basis of "ungraded with known treatment traces," and the room for negotiation usually widens noticeably.
For sellers, concealing treatment history may enable a short-term sale, but screening at the grading and inspection stages is tightening, and the probability of being identified is rising. For buyers, transactions involving high-priced vintage cards and modern chase cards should focus more on the card's provenance and whether it has been treated, rather than only on the score.
Self-Check Order Before Submission: Judge First, Then Decide
When facing a card with creases or stains, the rational order is to first judge which type of problem it is, then decide whether to submit—not to treat first and submit afterward.
- Record the original state: Before addressing any problem, first photograph the location and extent of creases, stains, and edge and corner issues as a basis for later judgment.
- Distinguish defect types: Creases are fiber deformation, while stains are surface attachments; their treatment logic and grading risks differ and cannot be lumped together.
- Verify the criteria: Confirm the target grading organization's current classification of pressing, cleaning, and trimming; PSA has already listed pressed creases as N5 or rejected and returned.
- Assess score and price gap: Compare the card's transaction range in its current state versus at an ideal score, and judge whether the potential gain from treatment is worth the risk of an Altered determination.
- Make the submission or retention decision: If the treatment method falls in a gray area of classification, submitting in the original state is usually more controllable than risking alteration.
What the Alteration Surge Really Means for the Collecting Market
The surge in alteration cases reflects the overexploitation of the strong link between grading scores and prices. When score differences can be directly converted into price gaps, the incentive to alter cards increases; and rising interception data shows that the grading stage is tightening this gray chain again.
For collectors, this means two things: first, the score of a high-value card is no longer a single signal that can be trusted unconditionally—provenance and treatment history need to be examined alongside it; second, the risks of "seemingly harmless" operations such as pressing and cleaning have been explicitly flagged and should no longer be spread as maintenance techniques.
At the market level, if altered cards continue to be intercepted, the scarcity of untreated cards will instead be reinforced, and cards with genuine condition and clear provenance will have more stable bargaining power in transactions. This is not a price forecast, but a natural extension of supply-and-demand logic after the criteria tighten.

