Collectors Antitrust Lawsuit Advances, BGS Low-Price Tiers Restricted: Submission Strategy Under a Grading Oligopoly
After Collectors came to control nearly 80% of the grading market, antitrust litigation has advanced; it is seeking to move the case to arbitration and to have it dismissed. BGS entry channels are restricted, with only high-price tiers running normally, and the squeeze on low-price services is forcing stricter defect and alteration screening before submission.
On this page
Litigation Advances as BGS Tier Availability Shrinks
At the time of reporting, two main threads are pressing on the grading market at once. First, after acquiring SGC and Beckett (BGS), PSA's parent company Collectors Holdings controls nearly 80% of the grading market, and several antitrust class actions are advancing; Collectors is actively seeking to move the plaintiffs' claims to arbitration and to have them dismissed. Second, BGS is dealing with website maintenance and backlog pressure, its entry channels are extremely restricted, and only high-price tiers such as Express are running normally.
These two developments are not part of the same causal chain, but for collectors they land as the same result: low-price, high-volume submission outlets have narrowed, while high-price tiers keep operating. Understanding this is more useful for today's submission decisions than arguing over who is right in the litigation.
Tiers and Market Position Compared
Organizing public information by "service tier — current status — meaning for submitters" makes clear which layer the squeeze is happening in.
| Service tier | Current status | Meaning for submitters |
|---|---|---|
| BGS entry/standard tiers | Extremely restricted, affected by website maintenance and backlog | Low-price bulk submission channels are largely unreliable |
| BGS Express and other high-price tiers | Running normally | Still usable when single-card value is high and turnaround matters |
| Overall market | Collectors-affiliated entities control nearly 80% share | Bargaining room and alternatives have narrowed |
The table reflects only the public status at the time of reporting; tiers may recover or tighten further as maintenance and backlog conditions change.
Closed Low-Price Channels Do Not Mean Demand Has Disappeared
Common myth
Restricted entry tiers show that collectors have stopped submitting and grading demand is fading.
Physical reality
What is restricted is low-price processing capacity on the supply side, not demand itself. Under backlog and maintenance pressure, organizations prioritize high-price tiers and compress low-price tiers.
If low-price tiers remain unavailable for a long time, mid- and low-value cards that would have gone through bulk channels will sit with collectors or move to other organizations; if the litigation brings structural change, both share and tier strategy could be reshuffled. Both are conditional inferences, not statistical conclusions that have already occurred.
The direct implication for submitters is this: do not misread "I can't get it in right now" as "this card isn't worth submitting," and do not treat "high-price tiers still work" as "every card should go through the high-price tier."
Two Paths: Bulk Low-Price and Single-Card High-Price
Bulk low-price submission** Mid- to low-value cards in large numbers rely on the low per-unit price of entry tiers to spread costs; with channels currently restricted, timing and outcome uncertainty are high.
Single-card high-price submission** High-value cards that are sensitive to turnaround and encapsulation outcomes can still use tiers such as Express, which run normally; the per-unit price is high, so it suits only a small number of cards.
The key choice is not whether a tier is expensive, but whether single-card value can cover that tier's cost and wait. The bulk path should be paused while channels are restricted, not forced through by paying more; the single-card path should first confirm whether the card really deserves to occupy a high-price tier.
Pre-Submission Screening Steps After Channels Narrow
- Check tier availability first: confirm whether the target tier is currently running normally, so you do not budget on old prices and old turnaround times.
- Go through corners and edges item by item: under side lighting, look for corner wear, whitening, and chipping, and record locations.
- Check surface and centering: look for scratches, indentations, creases, and print lines, and roughly estimate border ratios.
- Screen for signs of alteration and trimming: abnormally even edges, uneven color, and size deviations all need to be flagged.
- Sort by single-card value: only cards that can cover the cost of a high-price tier enter the single-card path; the rest are paused.
- Keep image records: photograph the full view and close-ups of defects before submission for comparison when results return.
The Most Common Cost Trap When Channels Tighten
When channels are restricted, the most common mistake is to pay more to push mid- and low-value cards into high-price tiers, hoping to "just get them out the door." The consequence is that the grading cost per card exceeds the card's comparable sale price, making it hard to recoup even with a grade; next is ignoring the longer turnaround caused by backlog and tying up funds in cards that do not return for a long time; third is submitting without screening for alterations and trimming, only to have the card flagged as altered, sharply reducing its value. The alternative is to complete screening and tier sorting first, and let only cards that truly deserve it enter normally running tiers.
Common Questions About the Lawsuit and Restricted Tiers
Will the antitrust lawsuit immediately change grading prices or tiers?
No. The litigation is still advancing, and Collectors is seeking to move it to arbitration and to have it dismissed; both the outcome and timing are uncertain. What can be confirmed now is the state in which BGS entry channels are restricted and high-price tiers are running normally.
Should cards still be sent for grading now?
It depends on single-card value and tier availability. High-value single cards can still go through normally running high-price tiers; for mid- and low-value bulk cards, it is more prudent to complete screening and records before entry channels recover.

